|
The Nuclear
Question
Nuclear
Energy on the surface is the most promising of the current "Big 3" energy
industries being Oil, Coal and Nuclear. I say that because in its normal
operation it is the least damaging to the environment and is the most
cost efficient of the three.
However...
You must
take into consideration the mining of uranium which can be just as bad
as the strip mining and mountain top removal mining of coal. Uranium
makes up less then .01% of the earth removed in "surface
Mining" or "open pit" mining AKA strip mining. 85 to 90%
of the 1% can be recovered through a several different processes.
If the ore
contains enough uranium it can be extracted in a mill, if the yield is
less, it is done through Heap Leaching. Leaching liquid, normally
sulfuric acid is introduced into the top of a large pile of ore. Once it
reaches the bottom it is collected on a liner and then pumped to a
refinery. The problem with both of these processes is that there is very
large amounts of ore remaining and due to technical restrictions still
contain 5 to 15% of the uranium. As uranium decomposes it releases radon
gas which is a carcinogen not to mention potentially hazardous dust and
the leaching chemical residue. From my research I have not found where
this release of radon gas is controlled or restricted in any way.
The third is
called In Situ Leaching.

It is
painfully clear by looking at the above image just how potentially
hazardous this process can be. The risk of contaminating a large
underground water supply is quite high. This process is the least
expensive so the most probable if allowed.
Just like
coal and oil, no matter what you do using the material to generate
electricity, no matter how safe or clean one might claim it is there is
still the issues of accessing the fuel its self. Just like coal and oil
nuclear energy has its draw backs in electricity generation and its by
products.
If you have
a failure using coal or oil to generate electricity there can be devastating
environmental impact, injuries and loss of life which is unacceptable.
However with nuclear the impact can be incomprehensible.
In 1986 one the
reactors at the Chernobyl Nuclear Power Plant in the Ukraine in the former Soviet
Union exploded. The end result claimed the lives of over 150,000, by some
accounts over 400,000 and the contamination of thousands of square miles of land
rendering it useless and dangerous for over 600 years. Not to mention the birth defects and cancer patients as a direct
result of the contamination. Had the wind been blowing in another direction,
over one million people could have died. Needless to say, the safety systems employed
at Chernobyl were virtually non existent as compared to the US nuclear plants.
The problem there is that nothing is 100%, just ask NASA and the people of
Middletown Pennsylvania.
In 1979, reactor
unit 2 at the Three Mile Island Nuclear Power Plant malfunctioned creating a
potential hazard to hundreds of thousand of people. Luckily a major disaster was
averted, but it came dangerously close and I am confident to say that if we
continue to operate our current nuclear plants and build new ones, it will
happen again and we might not be so lucky the second time around, it is truly
tempting fate.
The nuclear
industry will insist that their plants are safe and a accident can not
happen. this claim they must make in order to get licensed. They must
show on paper that the plant can not fail overall, that the system will
not allow for a catastrophic event. The more complicated something
becomes the more susceptible to failure it becomes. There have been more
nuclear accidents in this country then most people know about.
Here is a
great website with a comprehensive listing of accidents occurring in the
nuclear industry, civilian and military.
US
Nuclear Accidents
I
will only list here accidents from 1975 to 2002, you will be amazed, we
are very lucky. It is not my intention to bore you with miles of
information, I just want you to get an idea of how many problems there
have been, take a quick look.
22
March 1975
A technician checking for air leaks with a lighted candle caused
$100 million in damage when insulation caught fire at the Browns
Ferry reactor in Decatur, Alabama. The fire burned out
electrical controls, lowering the cooling water to dangerous
levels, before the plant could be shut down.
28 March 1979
A major accident at the Three Mile Island nuclear plant near
Middletown, Pennsylvania. At 4:00 a.m. a series of human and
mechanical failures nearly triggered a nuclear disaster. By 8:00
a.m., after cooling water was lost and temperatures soared above
5,000 degrees, the top portion of the reactor's 150-ton core
collapsed and melted. Contaminated coolant water escaped into a
nearby building, releasing radioactive gasses, leading as many
as 200,000 people to flee the region. Despite claims by the
nuclear industry that "no one died at Three Mile
Island," a study by Dr. Ernest J. Sternglass, professor of
radiation physics at the University of Pittsburgh, showed that
the accident led to a minimum of 430 infant deaths.
1981
The Critical Mass Energy Project of Public Citizen, Inc.
reported that there were 4,060 mishaps and 140 serious events at
nuclear power plants in 1981, up from 3,804 mishaps and 104
serious events the previous year.
11 February 1981
An Auxiliary Unit Operator, working his first day on the new job
without proper training, inadvertently opened a valve which led
to the contamination of eight men by 110,000 gallons of
radioactive coolant sprayed into the containment building of the
Tennessee Valley Authority's Sequoyah I plant in Tennessee.
July 1981
A flood of low-level radioactive wastewater in the sub-basement
at Nine Mile Point's Unit 1 (in New York state) caused
approximately 150 55-gallon drums of high-level waste to
overturn, some of which released their highly radioactive
contents. Some 50,000 gallons of low-level radioactive water
were subsequently dumped into Lake Ontario to make room for the
cleanup. The discharge was reported to the Nuclear Regulatory
Commission, but the sub-basement contamination was not. A report
leaked to the press 8 years later resulted in a study which
found that high levels of radiation persisted in the still
flooded facility.
1982
The Critical Mass Energy Project of Public Citizen, Inc.
reported that 84,322 power plant workers were exposed to
radiation in 1982, up from 82,183 the previous year.
25 January 1982
A steam generator pipe broke at the Rochester Gas & Electric
Company's Ginna plant near Rochester, New York. Fifteen thousand
gallons of radioactive coolant spilled onto the plant floor, and
small amounts of radioactive steam escaped into the air.
15-16 January 1983
Nearly 208,000 gallons of water with low-level radioactive
contamination was accidentally dumped into the Tennessee River at
the Browns Ferry power plant.
25 February 1983
A catastrophe at the Salem 1 reactor in New Jersey was averted
by just 90 seconds when the plant was shut down manually,
following the failure of automatic shutdown systems to act
properly. The same automatic systems had failed to respond in an
incident three days before, and other problems plagued this
plant as well, such as a 3,000 gallon leak of radioactive water
in June 1981 at the Salem 2 reactor, a 23,000 gallon leak of
"mildly" radioactive water (which splashed onto 16
workers) in February 1982, and radioactive gas leaks in March
1981 and September 1982 from Salem 1.
9
December 1986
A feedwater pipe ruptured at the Surry Unit 2 facility in
Virginia, causing 8 workers to be scalded by a release of hot
water and steam. Four of the workers later died from their
injuries. In addition, water from the sprinkler systems caused a
malfunction of the security system, preventing personnel from
entering the facility. This was the second time that an incident
at the Surry 2 unit resulted in fatal injuries due to scalding
[see also 27 July 1972].
1988
It was reported that there were 2,810 accidents in U.S.
commercial nuclear power plants in 1987, down slightly from the
2,836 accidents reported in 1986, according to a report issued
by the Critical Mass Energy Project of Public Citizen, Inc.
28 May 1993
The Nuclear Regulatory Commission released a warning to the
operators of 34 nuclear reactors around the country that the
instruments used to measure levels of water in the reactor could
give false readings during routine shutdowns and fail to detect
important leaks. The problem was first bought to light by an
engineer at Northeast Utilities in Connecticut who had been
harassed for raising safety questions. The flawed instruments at
boiling-water reactors designed by General Electric utilize
pipes which were prone to being blocked by gas bubbles; a
failure to detect falling water levels could have resulted,
potentially leading to a meltdown.
15 February 2000
New York's Indian Point II power plant vented a small amount of
radioactive steam when a an aging steam generator ruptured. The
Nuclear Regulatory Commission initially reported that no
radioactive material was released, but later changed their
report to say that there was a leak, but not of a sufficient
amount to threaten public safety.
6 March 2002
Workers discovered a foot-long cavity eaten into the reactor
vessel head at the Davis-Besse nuclear plant in Ohio. Borated
water had corroded the metal to a 3/16 inch stainless steel
liner which held back over 80,000 gallons of highly pressurized
radioactive water. In April 2005 the Nuclear Regulatory
Commission proposed fining plant owner First Energy 5.4 million
dollars for their failure to uncover the problem sooner (similar
problems plaguing other plants were already known within the
industry), and also proposed banning System Engineer Andrew
Siemaszko from working in the industry for five years due to his
falsifying reactor vessel logs. As of this writing the fine and
suspension were under appeal. |
So,
as you can see, it has not just been the Three Mile Island incident but
many others. The bottom line is Nuclear Energy may be by far the safest
based on technology but it is by far the most devastating
when you consider that one accident
can kill hundreds of thousands
and render massive areas uninhabitable
for hundreds of years. Then there is the problem of the highly
radioactive waste transportation and storage.
The
current answer? Pack 15,400,000 pounds of highly radioactive
waist on trains and ship it cross country
through major metropolitan
areas and then bury it in Nevada. There are hundreds of rail accidents a
year, derailments, crossing accidents and train to train collisions. It
will only take one catastrophic accident to kill hundreds, thousands,
hundreds of thousands, more? Every time we bury a hazardous waste no matter how well contained it gets out. It
makes
its way into the water and eventually makes its way to the surface and
that in my opinion is a risk we simply do not need to take. As a matter
of fact with alternative
energy where it is today and where it will be tomorrow there is no need
to consider the risk nuclear energy poses. Some corporate entities and
their puppet
law makers might beg to differ.
You
decide.
Below
are some links to sites regarding nuclear issues
and damage. I have also included pictures from damage done from
the Chernobyl
incident and a couple
of videos. Be warned, one of the videos
"The Children of
Chernobyl" contains very disturbing images that
everyone needs
to see. |